10 MINUTES AGO 🚨 In an interview, Myles Garrett answered a question comparing him to Josh Allen. He said that Josh Allen will never reach his level and most of Josh Allen’s great plays or scores are just due to luck.

Josh Allen even said that if Garrett played for his team, he would only be at a B-team level. Immediately, Josh Allen fired back with a concise ten-word response, leaving Myles Garrett stunned, speechless, and now facing penalties from both his own team and the NFL for those comments.

Just ten minutes ago, the NFL world was set ablaze when Cleveland Browns superstar defensive end Myles Garrett unleashed a series of inflammatory comments about Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen during a live radio interview on 92.3 The Fan.

When asked how he would compare his own dominance to Allen’s play on the opposite side of the ball, Garrett did not hold back.

“Josh Allen will never reach my level,” Garrett declared confidently. “Most of those highlight-reel plays, those deep bombs, those comeback wins—they’re luck. Pure luck. The guy scrambles around, throws it up, and somehow it works out. That’s not elite.

That’s fortunate.” The 2023 Defensive Player of the Year went further, adding a particularly stinging hypothetical: “If Myles Garrett played on Josh Allen’s team, I’d be the star. If he played on mine? He’d be B-team at best. Maybe even practice squad on a bad day.”

The comments, delivered with Garrett’s trademark intensity, immediately went viral. Social media erupted with reactions ranging from Browns fans cheering their franchise cornerstone to Bills Mafia defending their quarterback with characteristic fervor.

Analysts across networks began dissecting the feud, noting the long-standing respect the two players had publicly shown each other in past matchups—Allen once called Garrett “the best defender I’ve ever faced,” while Garrett had praised Allen’s “freakish athleticism.”

But the real fireworks were yet to come.

Within moments of the clip hitting X, Josh Allen—known for his laid-back personality and reluctance to engage in trash talk—responded directly on his verified account with a devastating ten-word reply that has already been called one of the coldest comebacks in recent NFL history:

“Luck is when preparation meets opportunity. Keep watching film, Myles.”

The post, accompanied by a simple shrug emoji, racked up over 500,000 likes in under ten minutes. Garrett, who was still in the studio wrapping up the interview when Allen’s response dropped, was shown the tweet live on air.

Cameras captured the exact moment he read it—his confident smirk vanished, his eyes widened, and for several long seconds, he was utterly speechless. The hosts pressed for a reaction, but Garrett could only manage a quiet “I’m good” before abruptly ending the segment.

The exchange has sent shockwaves through the league, and the consequences for Garrett appear swift and severe. Sources inside the Cleveland Browns organization confirm that head coach Kevin Stefanski and general manager Andrew Berry held an emergency meeting with Garrett immediately after the interview.

The team is reportedly preparing an internal fine—believed to be in the six-figure range—for violating the organization’s media policy on respecting opponents. One front-office insider told ESPN, “We love Myles’ fire, but there’s a line. Calling another superstar’s success ‘luck’ and demoting him to B-team crosses it.

This distracts from what we’re building.”

The NFL itself is also reviewing the comments under its player conduct policy. League spokesman Brian McCarthy confirmed that the office of football operations is examining whether Garrett’s remarks constitute “conduct detrimental to the league,” particularly given the inflammatory nature of dismissing a peer’s accomplishments as mere fortune.

Penalties could range from a public reprimand to a significant fine, with some analysts speculating upwards of $100,000 given recent precedents involving public criticism of fellow players.

This isn’t the first time Garrett has courted controversy with his words. The former No. 1 overall pick has built a reputation as one of the league’s most outspoken defenders, previously calling out officials, teammates, and even opposing quarterbacks.

But never before has he targeted a single player with such pointed dismissal of their entire body of work. Josh Allen, a two-time MVP runner-up who has led the Bills to five straight playoff appearances and holds numerous franchise records, represents perhaps the worst possible target for such criticism.

Allen’s response—measured, clever, and devastating—has been widely praised as a masterclass in handling provocation. Hall of Fame quarterback Kurt Warner tweeted, “That’s how you shut it down. Ten words. No anger.

Just truth.” Former teammate Stefon Diggs, now with Houston, posted laughing emojis with the caption “Big bro don’t miss.” Even neutral observers marveled at the precision: Allen essentially turned Garrett’s “luck” accusation into an acknowledgment of his own superior preparation, while subtly suggesting Garrett spend more time studying tape than talking.

The personal rivalry between the two has deeper roots. In their last meeting—a 31-23 Bills victory in 2024—Garrett recorded two sacks on Allen but was visibly frustrated as the quarterback repeatedly escaped pressure to extend plays and convert third downs.

Allen finished that game with 312 passing yards and three total touchdowns, repeatedly targeting the side opposite Garrett. Some believe lingering frustration from those matchups fueled today’s outburst.

For the Browns, the timing could not be worse. Sitting at 8-7 and fighting for a wildcard spot, Cleveland needs complete focus heading into their final two games. Instead, the organization now deals with a distracted superstar and national headlines questioning team culture.

Stefanski, when reached for comment, said only, “We’ve addressed it internally. Myles is a leader on this team, and we expect better.”

Garrett himself has gone silent on social media since the interview, deleting the original radio appearance clip from his stories. Friends close to the defender say he is “fuming” at Allen’s response but recognizes he may have gone too far.

One teammate anonymously told The Athletic, “Myles says what he feels, but Josh just cooked him with facts. We’re all telling him to let it go—actions on the field will speak louder anyway.”

As the story continues to dominate sports talk shows, betting odds have already shifted for their potential next matchup in the playoffs, with Allen now a heavier favorite in player prop markets. Merchandise sellers are rushing “Luck is preparation meeting opportunity” T-shirts into production for Bills fans.

What began as a routine radio hit has spiraled into one of the most talked-about player feuds of the 2025 season. Myles Garrett wanted to assert dominance. Instead, Josh Allen reminded everyone why he’s considered one of the league’s elite—not through bravado, but through quiet, devastating competence.

Ten words. That’s all it took.

And for Myles Garrett, those ten words may end up being very expensive.