The world of tennis has always been a hotbed for drama on and off the court, but the 2025 US Open has taken things to a new level with what many are calling the biggest love scandal of the year. Supermodel Brooks Nader, the stunning face of Sports Illustrated Swimsuit and a fixture at high-profile events, is at the center of swirling rumors that she was dating both Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner during the tournament. The whispers, fueled by social media sleuths and paparazzi shots, have sent fans into a frenzy, pitting the two young stars against each other in a narrative that’s as captivating as any five-set thriller.
Nader, 28, was spotted in the stands at Flushing Meadows multiple times, her effortless style turning heads amid the New York buzz. On Day 3, she was seen cheering for Alcaraz, the 22-year-old Spanish sensation who defended his US Open title with a dominant run to the semifinals. Dressed in a sleek white ensemble, Nader exchanged knowing smiles with the Spaniard after his straight-sets win over Tommy Paul, leading to speculation of a budding romance. Sources claim the pair met at a pre-tournament party in Manhattan, bonding over shared interests in fashion and fitness. Alcaraz, ever the charmer, reportedly dedicated his victory to “someone special” in his post-match interview, a vague nod that only added fuel to the fire.
But the plot thickened on Day 7, when Nader appeared courtside for Sinner’s quarterfinal match against Ben Shelton. The 24-year-old Italian, who clinched the tournament with a gritty final win over Alexander Zverev, seemed equally smitten. Eyewitnesses described a flirtatious exchange during a changeover, with Nader handing Sinner a towel and the two sharing a lingering laugh. Social media exploded with side-by-side photos of Nader with both players, hashtagged #BrooksTriangle, as fans dissected every angle. “Is she playing both sides of the net?” one viral tweet quipped, capturing the panic and excitement rippling through the tennis community.
The scandal has fans in a tailspin, with online forums buzzing about potential fallout. Alcaraz and Sinner, who share a respectful rivalry—having faced off in epic matches like their 2024 French Open semifinal—are now the unwitting stars of a soap opera. Supporters of the Spaniard accuse Nader of stringing him along, while Sinner’s loyalists hail her as the perfect match for the world No. 1. The drama peaked when anonymous sources leaked texts allegedly showing Nader coordinating her appearances, though authenticity remains unverified. Nader herself has stayed coy, posting cryptic Instagram stories of champagne toasts and court views, captioned simply “Summer love?” Her silence only amplifies the intrigue.
This love triangle comes at a time when both players are navigating peak careers. Alcaraz, with four Grand Slams under his belt, is eyeing a calendar-year Grand Slam, while Sinner’s US Open triumph solidifies his dominance. Yet, the off-court buzz threatens to overshadow their achievements, drawing parallels to past tennis romances like Maria Sharapova and Grigor Dimitrov. Experts warn that such scandals can affect focus, but insiders say both athletes are brushing it off as “New York noise.”
As the US Open aftermath lingers, the Brooks Nader saga has tennis fans hooked, blending glamour, rivalry, and heartbreak. Will she choose one, or keep the court divided? For now, the panic is palpable, proving that in the world of aces and errors, love serves up the biggest surprises.
